Autor: sosciso

Autor: Jonathan Schultz, (BarraQDA.org)

Summary

NVivotools provides a way to interface NVivo with other software tools. It can be used at each stage of the QDA process – data entry, coding, analysis, reporting and archiving. This blog post outlines how it works and its potential applications. It then describes the author’s experience of using it in a simple real-world example.

Introduction

NVivo is probably the most widely used software for QDA. It provides an integrated GUI-driven system for managing, coding and reporting on research material in textual, audio and video form. Yet it suffers from a number of shortcomings, some of which NVivotools seeks to overcome. Most notably:

1. NVivo uses a closed (proprietary) data format to ‘lock up’ your data and prevent you from using other software with it. By freeing your research data from this environment, NVivotools lets you use the wide range of free and non-free tools for data harvesting, manipulation, coding, analysis, reporting and archiving.

2. NVivo requires a fairly powerful Windows or Mac computer. There is no chance of coding on a portable device or Linux box, and even your old Windows computer will struggle with any but the smallest research project. By using the simple and lightweight SQLite database and allowing you to use your own tools, NVivotools makes computer assisted QDA accessible on smaller and cheaper devices, including Linux machines.

3. NVivo’s GUI is great for users who are starting out and need help finding their way around, but for everyone else it quickly becomes a handicap. It makes small errors almost inevitable and provides no means of validation as it leaves no record of the steps that have been taken, and it cannot be automated. NVivotools provides another way to work on your research data using powerful scripting languages such as R and Python.

How it works

NVivotools accesses NVivo files (which are actually database files – Microsoft SQL Server for the Windows edition and SQL Anywhere for the Mac edition). It provides command-line tools to transform NVivo data from an NVivo file into and out a simpler and more easily accessed database, which it refers to as the normalised database. Because NVivotools uses the Python module SQLAlchemy for database access, it is able to deploy many different database engines for the normalised database. By far the simplest of these is SQLite, and NVivotools largely assumes that this is the one you will use.

The normalised database format is (almost) self-explanatory. Files can be opened with any program that can read SQLite files (try SQLiteBrowser as a first point of call) and the structure and content of the NVivo project data extracted, modified, added to or otherwise used at will. The data can also be re-imported into an NVivo project file, making any changes available within NVivo. In this way, researchers can tailor the data analysis to suit a particular project, and write or make use of existing tools to work with the data.

To use NVivotools, you can either install it on your own computer, or use an online version. In either case, it is free to use or redistribute, subject to the usual GPL licence conditions.

A simple example

As a demonstration of NVivo’s potential, the author took NVivo’s sample project for NVivo 10 for Windows, which can be downloaded here. This demonstration script uses Python’s textblob module to find the most commonly occurring noun phrases across all the sources in the project. It creates a node for a lemmatised version of each noun phrase, and codes every sentence that contains one of them at that node. In order to limit the number of noun phrases, it allows the user to specify the minimum number of times the noun phrase must occur to be included.

Installing textblob requires two commands:

 $ pip install textblob
 $ python -m textblob.download_corpora

To use NVivotools, first convert the sample project to a normalised database. This creates an output which by default has the same name as the input file, with the extension .nvp replaced by .norm:

 C:> NormaliseNVP.py Sample-Project-NVivo10.0-Format.nvp
 Using MSSQL instance: QSRNVIVO10
 File activation failure. The physical file name "C:\Users\jschultz\Documents\NVivo 10 Sample Project_log.LDF" 
 may be incorrect.
 New log file 'C:\Users\jschultz\AppData\Local\Temp\SQL\tmpdx9ri9_log.LDF' was created.
 Msg 15025, Level 16, State 1, Server WINDOWS7-TS\QSRNVIVO10, Line 1
 The server principal 'nvivotools' already exists.
 Attached database nt1456
 Normalising users
 Normalising project
 Normalising node categories
 Normalising nodes
 Normalising node attributes
 Normalising source categories
 Normalising sources
 Normalising source attributes
 Normalising taggings
 Normalising annotations
 Dropped database nt1456

Next, run the demonstration script with the occurrence threshold set to 5. Notice that the database engine is specified explicitly here as SQLite. This command does the actual textual analysis and adds the nodes and coding information to the normalised file.

 C:> textblobExampleCode.py --threshold 5 sqlite:///Sample-Project-NVivo10.0-Format.norm

The resulting data can then be reloaded into the original sample project file. If you try this with real live data, make sure you have a backup!

 C:> DenormaliseNVP.py Sample-Project-NVivo10.0-Format.norm Sample-Project-NVivo10.0-Format.nvp
 Using MSSQL instance: QSRNVIVO10
 File activation failure. The physical file name 
 "C:\Development\NVivo\Development\Main\NVivo\Installer\Client\Databases\Sample Project_log.LDF" may be incorrect.
 New log file 'C:\Users\jschultz\AppData\Local\Temp\SQL\tmpwsr7o4_log.LDF' was created.
 Msg 15025, Level 16, State 1, Server WINDOWS7-TS\QSRNVIVO10, Line 1
 The server principal 'nvivotools' already exists.
 Attached database nt3504
 Denormalising users
 Denormalising project
 Denormalising node categories
 Denormalising nodes
 Denormalising node attributes
 Denormalising source categories
 Denormalising sources
 Denormalising source attributes
 Denormalising taggings and/or annotations
 WARNING: Unrecognised tagging fragment: 0:-2 for Source: NC Sea Turtle Project
 WARNING: Unrecognised tagging fragment: 0:-2 for Source: Barrier island undeveloped
 Saved database nt3504

Don’t worry about those warnings – they refer to more complex coding from the NVivo project that NVivotools currently ignores. Now open the modified NVivo project file, and you can see the nodes that have been created under the top-level node ‘Noun Phrases’. In the screenshot below, you can see that the node ‘green turtles’ has been opened, and two of the 29 selections containing the words ‘green turtles’ can be seen.

Conclusion

As this simple example demonstrates, NVivotools makes it easy to retrieve your data from NVivo, from where it can be examined and analysed, and if required imported back into NVivo. This gives researchers great scope to integrate NVivo more strongly with existing IT systems at each phase of a research project. As NVivotools is written in Python and has an Open Source (GPLv3) licence, it is and will remain free to use, as well as to examine, fork, modify and contribute to. There is certainly scope for improvement and to build it into a more integrated engine for computer assisted QDA using Open Standards. Nonetheless in its current state, it can be a useful addition to a CAQDAS toolkit.